Right Question For this Answer (about count/rank/order)

Jun-Dai is admirably correct. The usage I personally find clearest is, "Which prime minister...."

Alternate take on this:

I was talking to some of my co-workers about this question today (using US Presidents as the example), and someone suggested:

"George Washington was the first President of the United States, and John Adams was the second; what is the current President?"

Hmm, it may be a grammatical mistake to troll grammatical questions with political views. :p

Thanks, raybid! You made my day. :D :D

"How manyth..."

Love it, love it. It is utterly wrong and utterly right at the same time.

I second that raybid!
And thanks Ramalingam for posting the question. I've been asking around my work place for this and no one seems to know. To them it's something they never think [to ask].

do not understand

Q. Complete this sentence: "Manmohan Singh is the Fouteenth Prime Minister of..."

The problem is that English is not mathematically complete.... Please forgive me for duplication of info, but I didn't read all comments 'cause I'm lazy (except with apostrophes). What you are looking for is the word "Whicheth" which does not exist. "Whicheth prime minister of India is Manmohan Singh?" is the only question which is guaranteed to yeild the desired response, given that the recipient of your importune is aware of its intended meaning. (Correction apparently somebody has coined the term how-manyth, but I'm biased to whicheth, 'cause I've been using it for years) The problem with "Which prime minister..." is that I could always respond "The one with the grey hair," or some such nonsense, and still answer correctly.

Forgive me for being didactic about a word that does not even exist, but I believe that if it did exist it would actually be spelled "whichth."

"Whicheth" sounds like the kind of fake King James Bible speech that we used to get in trouble for when we did in church as children: "Blessedeth be-eth they-eth thatteth mourneth, for they-eth shalleth be-eth comforted. Eth."

Heh.

Hi,
"Prime Mininsterial Cardianlity" seems to be perfect..

I like other replies too... "how manyth" , "whicheth"

Thank you one and all...

One of my colleagues asked me this question, I posted it here... ;-)

Thank You !

Regards,
Ram.

Myself: "What place in succession does Manmohan Singh have?"

You: "I believe he is the fourteenth, my good fellow."

OR, ALTERNATIVELY

You: " I believe he has the fourteenth place in succession, my delightful companion"

For what value of n is Manmohan Singh the nth Prime Minister of India?

Ha! I got it...

"What number is Manmohan Singh in the succession of Prime Ministers of India?"

This will return "fourteen," but, understanding the intent of the question, many people will probably answer "He's the fourteenth Pime Minister."

Though it is very tempting to use words like whichth and howmanyeth I believe that the right usage is the word cardinality.

What is the Prime Ministerial cardinality of ManMohan Singh

What is your cardinality of birth

Though the use of the word Cardinality for this particular usage has not been documented in any Dictionary, i believe it has been used by other writers before overlooked during the making of Dictionary

I am sorry, I correct my last Post

The word is not Cardinality but ORDINALITY

What is the Prime Ministerial ordinality of ManMohan Singh

What is your ordinality of birth

Hi,
I Thank You All.
But I couldn't get a result for "ordinality" when I search in

http://dictionary.reference.com/search?q=ordinality
http://www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary?book=Dictionary&va=ordinality

We may use ordinal position instead...

I really appreciate your help. Thanks !

Regards,
Ram.

i would like to know right usage in given bellow
1. wat is the prime ministerial cardinality of manmohan singh

2. what is the prime ministerial ordinality of manmohan singh

While some comments are on the right track, I would suggest the somewhat simpler: "Ordinally, which prime minister if India is Manmohan Singh?" As mentioned above, cardinal is incorrect as it does not imply any information about order. Cardinal numbers are one, two, three; ordinal numbers are first, second, third.... Regarding the list of presidents in the US, cardinality simply refers to the total number of presidents, forty-four (possibly forty-three, as Cleveland served two non-consecutive terms?).

I wanted to suggest something about order of succession or sequence, but unfortunately, that would be incorrect as it already refers to the order in which other officers fill in if the president or prime minister leaves office. E.g., in the US, the Vice President, then Speaker of the House, etc., are next in the order of succession if the President can no longer serve.

Oops, sorry. That's "Ordinally, which prime minister of India is Manmohan Singh?", "of" not "if".

Which Prime Minister of India is Manmohan Singh?
What number Prime Minister of India is Manmohan Singh?
I think, these would be sufficient for the expected ordinal numbers.

The correct way to ask is
What is the ordinal position of Manmohan singh among the Prime Ministers of India?
Never say ordinal status as commonly used, because the word status has more deep meaning.
Thank you

Chronologically,which Indian prime minister is Manmohan Sing?

what is the numerological position of Manmohan sing among prime ministers of india

what is the neumorological position of Prime Minister Manmohansing?

The "numerological" position has nothing to do with the order. Numerology is the superstitious occult study of numbers (usually one's birthday) as they affect the outcome of our lives. It's the "astrology" of numbers. I don't think "neumorological" or neumorology is even a word.

I would go for this one:
What number of prime ministerial position does Mr. Manmohan Sing have?
What do u suggest guys?
Thanks
Riz

Jawaharlal Nehru was the first prime minister of India. What number is Manmohan Singh?

WHAT IS THE ORDINAL NUMBER OF MANMOHAN SINGH AMONG THE PRIME MINISTERS OF INDIA?

I think,
What is the ordinal position(or number) of Manmohan Sing among the prime ministers of India?

I Think

What is the ordinal position of Manmohan sing among the prime ministers of india ? is the correct usage.

Hi frnd .. the correct question for this would be....

What is Manmohan singh's ordinal as the Prime minister of the India?

You can get the response you want by asking this question:

What does the following say: 'Manmohan Singh is the Fouteenth Prime Minister of India'?

The correct question would be:

What is the ordinal position of Manmohan Singh as the Prime Minister of India?

As a prime minister of India ,Manmohan Singh holds which rank ?

What is the ordinal position of Manmohan Sing among the prime Ministers of India?

Thank you Mr Ramalingamchellia for asking such a question
I olso want to know the same mater. I got the solusionfrom your blog what I am searching for a long time and also thanks to the site

What is the ordinal status of Barack Obama as the president of us?

I think the simplest one is " Which of the Indian Prime Ministers was Manmohan Singh?"

In the Indian Political History In which numerical order does our Prime Minister Manmohan Singh Comes ?

i think this is the correct question

What place in succession as a prime minister of india does Manmohan Singh have

What is the ordinal rank of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh?

which prime minister is Manmohan Singh according to his ordinal status?

where did we get the right answer?

'What is the ordinal number/chronological order of Dr Manmohan Singh as the prime minister/among the prime ministers of India?

chronologicaly which prime minister is Manmohan singh

what is the chronological order of manmohan singh among the PMs of india

What is the cronological number of Dr. Manmoham Singh being the Prime Minister of India

"What is the ordinal status of Dr.Manmohan Sing among the Prime Minister of India"

What is the order of succession Mr Manmohansigh as Prime Minister of India? or In what order does Mr Manmohansingh succeeds as PM of India?

I would like to know the Question to ask for which we get a reply like...

“Manmohan Singh is the Fouteenth Prime Minister of India.”

1. WHAT IS THE ORDINAL RANK OF DR. MANMOHAN SINGH AS THE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA
2.WHAT IS THE CHRONOLOGICAL ORDER OF DR. MANMOHAN SINGH AS THE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA

THE CORRECT ANSWER FOR THIS QUESTION IS
1) WHAT IS THE ORDINAL STATUS OF MANMOHAN SINGH AMONG THE INDIAN PRIME MINISTERS.

2)WHAT IS THE ORDINAL STATUS OF MANMOHAN SING AS THE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA..

What ordinal-number prime minister is Manmohan Singh?"

What is the chronological order of Manmohan Singh among prime minsters of India?

Question: What is the chronological order of Manmohan Singh as Prime minister of India ?

Answer: 14th

What is the "chronological position" of man Mohan Singh as a prime minister

In which prime ministrial election manmohan singh is elected aas president

As I answered to my friend, I found below answer is perfect for that,

"what is the position of Jawaharlal Nehru among Indian prime ministers??"

You can use this if you want.

Hope it will help you

Howmanyeth president was Manmohan Singh

"What is the position of Manmohan singh in the chronological order of Indian Prime ministers ?"
i know that your question was published in 2004..it is too late but it will be helpful for others....who are having similiar problems

hg

What's the ordinal rank of Manmohan Singh among the Prime Ministers of India?

what is the chronological order of manmohan singh as prime minister of india

What is the chronological order of Manmohan Singh as prime minister of India