Username
earltender
Member Since
April 7, 2003
Total number of comments
3
Total number of votes received
3
Bio
Latest Comments
There were/was an apple and an orange.
- April 11, 2003, 1:36am
Dyske,
If I saw the apple and the orange as a pair I would say "There was some fruit." Not to be facetious, but how you say something indicates how you saw it. If you say " There was an apple and an orange." then you perceived two different objects that were together, not a pair of like objects.
I guess...
Yoroshiku,
Earl
There were/was an apple and an orange.
- April 7, 2003, 2:11am
I don't think this is a "great question" as such. The "be" verb used is in the singular because the "be" verbs used prior to a conjunctive phrase are geared to the first part of the conjunction.
Ex. There were droplets and an intermittent drizzle.
This also applies to the the use of indefinite articles.
Email
To switch to "a piece of e-mail" would make you idiomize "piece" (since real mail comes in pieces). I prefer using "an e-mail" since it doesn't do that; it seems more accurate.
Given that "e-mail" is a new word in the language, how it is used is totally determined by the populace; "rules" just don't apply. As a student in the language I am sure that you realized early on that all the English "rules" were merely statements of general use. Taking all that into account, I prefer accuracy in the statement.
There are words that I wonder about, for instance is "daikon" a non-count or countable noun?
Also in Japanese, many Japanese really don't have a notion of "iru" and "aru" down very well; it seems to change from person to person and is very situational. This is more confusing to me.